Buying Out Unvested Equity to Win an Executive Offer

When a candidate forfeits stock, bonus, or a retention loan to join you, matching salary isn't enough — here's how to price, structure, and protect the buyout.

Hiring Managers & Executives · 6 min read · Oct 22, 2026

The short answer

Buying out a candidate's forfeited equity means verifying the actual vesting schedule and documentation first, then replacing it with a structured payout that includes its own retention lever — split between a start-date payment and an anniversary payment with a clawback — rather than handing over a lump sum that removes the old employer's handcuffs without installing any of your own.

Why Matching Salary Doesn't Close the Gap

When a senior candidate agrees to leave their current employer, salary and target bonus are rarely the whole story. Most mid-to-senior comp packages at any company with a stock plan include unvested RSUs or options, a deferred cash bonus tied to an anniversary date, or the back half of a forgivable relocation or signing loan. An offer that only replaces base and target bonus has matched the visible comp and ignored the part specifically designed to make leaving expensive.

This is the gap that kills offers in the final two weeks of a search — not because the candidate got cold feet, but because their spouse, their financial advisor, or their own quiet math turned up a six-figure hole your offer letter never addressed. By the time that surfaces, you're negotiating against the clock instead of against a number you could have priced up front.

What's Actually Being Forfeited

Break the forfeiture into categories before you price anything: unvested RSUs or options, a deferred or retention bonus that pays out on a future date, and any forgivable loan balance still outstanding. In private companies, add phantom equity or carried interest, which is harder to value and almost always overstated by the candidate.

The detail hiring managers get wrong most often is treating vesting as linear. Most plans run a one-year cliff followed by monthly or quarterly vesting after that. A candidate eleven months into their grant has vested nothing; one at thirteen months has a meaningful chunk already secured. Ask for the actual vesting date, not a percentage estimate, or you'll either overpay someone who had almost nothing at risk or underpay someone who was about to cross a cliff.

Verify the Number Before You Price the Offer Around It

Candidates negotiate forfeiture numbers the same way they negotiate salary — as an opening anchor, not an audited figure. Ask for the grant agreement or the vesting schedule from the equity management platform the current employer uses. For public company stock, the math is simple. For private company options, ask about the most recent valuation, the strike price, and whether there's been a tender offer, because candidates routinely price their options off the valuation reported in the press rather than their strike-adjusted, post-dilution actual value.

If someone can't produce documentation within about a week of the forfeiture conversation starting, treat their number as a negotiating position and build your offer off a conservative discount rather than their stated figure. You can always true it up once paperwork arrives; you can't easily claw back an overpayment made on a guess.

Structuring the Buyout So It Isn't Just Free Money

A single lump-sum signing bonus removes the old employer's retention lever and installs none of your own, which is backwards during the exact window — the first twelve to eighteen months — when a new senior hire is most likely to wash out or walk. Split the payment instead, and attach your own handcuff to it.

Say a controller candidate is forfeiting $140,000 in unvested RSUs that would have fully vested over the next sixteen months. Paying it all at the start date solves the candidate's math and solves none of yours. A more defensible structure: $50,000 at start to cover the immediate hole, $90,000 at the twelve-month anniversary, with full repayment required by promissory note if the person resigns voluntarily before month eighteen. You've replaced the economics the old employer built and reproduced the discipline.

Account for the tax mismatch before you promise a true like-for-like replacement. A signing bonus is ordinary income withheld at the supplemental wage rate; the equity being forfeited, had it vested, may have qualified for long-term capital gains treatment. A straight dollar-for-dollar replacement nets the candidate less than what they're walking away from. Either gross up for the differential explicitly, or tell the candidate plainly that the net replacement runs lower than face value — surfacing that in the offer conversation is cheaper than having the CFO discover it after the fact.

The Walk-Away Math

Add the buyout to the rest of what the hire already costs — the search fee, any relocation package, the comp premium over your internal pay bands — and compare the total to what the seat is actually worth to the business. If a $220,000-base role carries a 25% contingent search fee ($55,000) and now needs a $140,000 equity buyout, day-one acquisition cost before the person has worked an hour is roughly $195,000, close to 90% of first-year salary. That number needs sign-off from whoever owns the P&L the role reports into, not a quiet approval buried in HR.

Clawbacks are only as strong as your willingness to enforce them. Put the repayment terms in the offer letter and back them with a signed promissory note, not a verbal understanding at close. An unenforced clawback doesn't just cost you the money — it becomes the next company's forfeiture story when this same person leaves early for someone else.

Frequently asked

Good questions.

Should we always match 100% of what a candidate says they're forfeiting?

No. Treat the candidate's stated number as a starting point, not a fact, until you've seen the vesting schedule or grant agreement. Private company equity in particular is routinely overstated because candidates price it off headline valuations rather than strike-adjusted, post-dilution value. Build your initial offer off a conservative, documented estimate, then true it up once paperwork confirms the real figure.

What if the candidate won't or can't share their vesting documents?

Many employment agreements restrict disclosure of exact grant terms, so some hesitation is normal and not a red flag by itself. Ask for enough to verify the vesting date and share count without requiring the full agreement, and if nothing is forthcoming within about a week, price your offer conservatively rather than accepting an unverified number.

Is a signing bonus the same as equity for tax purposes?

No. A signing bonus is ordinary income taxed at the supplemental wage withholding rate, while unvested equity that would have vested often qualifies for lower capital gains treatment. A dollar-for-dollar cash replacement of forfeited equity value nets the candidate less than what they're giving up unless you gross up for the difference or are upfront that the net amount will run lower.

What happens to the clawback if we lay the person off before the repayment period ends?

Clawback language should trigger on voluntary resignation or termination for cause, not on layoff or termination without cause. Drafting it any other way turns a retention tool into a penalty for the employee for a decision the company made, and it won't hold up well if challenged. Separate the two triggers clearly in the promissory note.

Ready to make the hire?

Tell us the role, the comp band, and the timeline — we'll tell you exactly how we'd run the search.